Great formula, perfect to wear with or without a Colourpop Lippie Stix on top, and a great lip liner to wear in combination with some pastel eyeshadow. The MAC Chestnut lip liner is that really dark, cool-toned brown lip liner, perfect whether you have dark skin, brown skin or medium skin. A bit creamier, too, as you really won’t have to wear any lip primer underneath to make it glide on your lips. The Satin Kiss TGIF lip liner is that dark chocolate brown, much creamier than the MAC Chestnut lip liner. The color is almost similar to Chestnut, and perfect to wear for ombre lips or as a nude brown lip liner on brown and dark skin tones.

Lip Pencil | Lip Liner | NYX Professional Makeup Slim Lip Pencil | Lip Liner | NYX Professional Makeup

Why not try a look with a fiery orange eyeshadow, matching blush and the Maybelline Rich Chocolate lip liner all over your lips? Finish with clear lipgloss, and you’re good to go! Not an exact dupe for MAC Chestnut here, with the Kiko Smart Fusion lip liner in 531, but a close one all the same, and a perfect, perfect formula. If you’d like to go for a shade that looks more like the Stone lip liner, a bit more greyish, you also have the Smart Fusion 536 lip liner. I have come to find that the Barry M lip liners boast almost the same formula as the MAC lip liners. Oh boy, that one is probably one of the closest shades to the Chestnut lip liner, and the Rare Beauty lip liners are described as ‘smooth, balm-like’.

Pharmacy product

Other available colors: After Hours, Bedtime Flirt, Corset, Dust To Dawn, Embellishment, Exotic, Lace Detail, Push-Up, Seduction, Silk Indulgent, Teddy The LA Girl Chestnut lip liner seems to have been discontinued, but take a look at dollar stores and small indie makeup shops (or Beauty Base in the UK), and you’ll probably get your hands on it. Welcome to your lifestyle treasure trove for makeup bits to digital nomad bobs, candles and coworking spots. About as affordable as the NYX Espresso lip liner, you do have a great MAC Chestnut lip liner dupe in the Makeup Revolution brand. If you’re looking for the best MAC Chestnut lip liner dupe from Morphe, you’ve got the Color Pencil in Trendsetter.

Lip Liner - NYX Cosmetics Lip Liner - NYX Cosmetics

I used to use them on every photoshoots, and they’ve got the most perfect finish you could ever wish for, all that for a handful of dollars. I talked about some of the Nabla Close Up Lip Shapers here before in other MAC dupe guides, and here we go again, with the shade Nude #6.

Don't miss a thing

The texture is actually waterproof, and will remind lovers of the now-discontinued MAC Pro Longwear lip liners of that exact same formula. SLIM LIP PENCIL, ESPRESSO (brown lip liner): NYX Professional Makeup Slim Lip Pencil natural lip liner pencils come in a variety of dashing shades from auburn to orange and traffic stopping red to line and define your lips Not an exact MAC Chestnut lip liner dupe with this one, but still an honorable mention – the NYX Slide On lip liner in Urban Cafe. If you can get your hands on this one, you’ll find the texture is absolutely gorgeous, and you’ve got in the Rich Mitch lip liner what could probably be the best MAC Chestnut lip liner dupe.

NYX Professional Makeup Suede Matte Lipstick Pencil | NYX Professional Makeup

But some drugstore brands like NYX have achieved the perfect formula for their products, and don’t break the bank; far from it. The MUA Makeup Academy products are amazing, and while they’re mostly available in the UK rather than the USA, you can still get them from some online shops. You don't have permission to access "http://www.superdrug.com/make-up/lips/lip-liners/nyx-professional-makeup-slim-lip-pencil-shade-espresso/p/826591" on this server.A perfect formula at half price of what you’d pay for the real deal, and obviously, there are many more shades in the range you’ll want to get when you try this one. Expect a bit more lasting time as you would for the MAC lip liners, as this one is waterproof, and you can also expect more comfort throughout the day. Indeed, the LA Girl lip liners are known for being some of the cheapest in the makeup industry – and you can get them in shops like Target too!

NYX Professional Makeup Slim Lip Pencil, Long-Lasting Creamy NYX Professional Makeup Slim Lip Pencil, Long-Lasting Creamy

It seems that while the Morphe lip liners are available in plenty of shades, they do seem to cater to fair skin the most. A little bit more chocolate-toned where the Chestnut lip liner seems a bit more muted in its brown color, but still, at that price, you really can’t go wrong. Another really good drugstore dupe for MAC Chestnut lip liner, with that top formula that seems to be Maybelline’s signature move. Hopefully, you’ll have found here perfect options to suit your budget; finding the best MAC Chestnut lip liner dupe is actually much easier than finding one for Soar, Whirl or Spice.Given that the formula is creamier, the lasting time is a bit shortened, but your lips will suffer less/need less of a lip balm and lip primer for all day wear. Other available colors: Beige, Bloom, Coffee, Espresso, Ever, Hot Red, Mahogany, Mauve, Natural, Nude Punk, Plum, Prune, Pale Pink, Rose, Sand Pink And you should wish to; in the UK, the MUA Makeup Academy lip liners are some of the most affordable, even more affordable than the Barry M lip liners, and longer! However, since it’s completely waterproof, you’ll also use less product, and the Lip Shaper #6 will actually last you longer in time.